All Rubber Is Not Created Equal: The Five Commandments of Tires
Posted in Watches & Race Equipment, Tech Talk by Jordan RappBefore going any further, I want to emphasize that I will NOT get mired down in the tubular vs. clincher debate here (at least not in this entry). The purpose of this post is more to address the issue of choosing tires. Not necessarily the “right” tire, but going over differences in tire construction, choosing pressures, etc.
Michelin gives useful rankings on their website, rating each tire in terms of grip, comfort, rolling resistance, puncture resistance, weight, durability, and price. They key concept is that you can’t get something for nothing. If you want light weight, you will probably give up some durability.
If you want a lower price, you will probably give up some rolling resistance performance. A tire with a lot of puncture resistance might be a bit less comfortable. Finding the right tire is about evaluating what you want for each situation. So, this brings up to tire commandment #1:
Thou shalt have racing tires and training tires, and they shalt not be the same.
These most important criteria for race tires are, in order of importance: rolling resistance, puncture resistance, grip, weight, durability, price. Depending on how skilled you are at changing a tire, you may swap puncture resistance and rolling resistance. Fortunately, there are a lot of good tires out there where you don’t have to make this choice.
The Michelin ProRace (slightly better rolling resistance) and Ironman (slightly better grip) tires offer excellent puncture resistance so that you do not suffer a loss of air from your tires (otherwise known as a f–t — don’t say the word for karmic reasons) and among the best rolling resistance coefficients in the business.
Unfortunately, they only make clincher tires, so if you are interested in tubulars, you need to look elsewhere. They are, however, not tires that last forever since the rubber is very soft, which is why they ride so nicely.
This is true not only of Michelins, but of any top-quality, low-rolling resistance tire. They tend to wear qucikly, which is why I’d use these tires only when racing. If you like the cushy ride and don’t mind paying a bit more for nice tires a bit more often, then by all means, use the same tires for racing as for training, but do keep a separate pair of tires on hand as race-day tires, so that you are racing on fresh rubber.
For training tires, I rank the following way: puncture resistance, durability, price, rolling resistance, grip, weight. Fortunately, there are several great options for training tires that are moderately prices and offer exellent durability, while not making you feel like the fillings are coming out of your teeth when you ride down the road.
I use the Michelin Krylion Carbon as my training tire, and I’ve been getting about 2500 miles per pair. The back goes first, and I could rotate them, but I just toss the back tire, get a new pair, and designate the front as a training tire for the winter. Which brings up to commandment #2:
Thou shalt endeavour to use a specific tire for the indoor trainer.
Nothing chews up a tire quicker than an aluminum roller on a trainer. So if you know you are going to be riding on the trainer regularly, such as in the winter for those of us in colder climates, make sure you use a tire just for the trainer.
This offers two big advantages - first, you won’t care that the tire gets burned up really quickly, and since you are not going anywhere, you can get a cheap tire that doesn’t have good features anywhere else. That budget touring tire works just fine on the trainer.
Second, you won’t worry about the trainer grinding bits of road debris deep into your regular tires, so that when you do head out on the road, you won’t worry that you tire might give way should you encounter some small obstacle seeking to remove air from your tires. Which brings us to commandment #3:
Thou shalt inspectest your tires regularly before usage.
Don’t just assume that you made it safely through that field of broken Heinekens. Actually check to make sure you did. Use tweezers or a small screwdriver to pry bit of glass and road debris out of the tire. Take care of your tires, and they will take care of you! (Okay that was a bit over the top, but you get the point). Getting the most out of your tires, whatever that means for your situation - mileage or speed - means attention to the details.
But what about what goes inside your tires? For clincher users this has two meanings, tubes and air. For those on tubulars, I’m just talking about air. We’ll cover the tube issue first, because it is quicker. There are two kinds of tubes - latex and butyl. 99.44% of you probably have only ever used butyl tubes. These are the black tubes that you think of a bicycle tubes.
But there is another option - latex. Latex tubes are made from natural rubber and are usually semi-transparent and pink or green or tan, but never black. Butyl tubes came about long before I was born when there was a shortage of natural rubber. Butyl turned out to be a great substance for making inner-tubes. Some say better than latex. Butyl is tougher than latex, meaning it is harder for an object to puncture. This is why it is so nice for your everyday tube.
BUT, latex does still offer a couple advantages. It is more supple than butyl, meaning if you have a supple (i.e. low rolling resistance tire), using a latex tube will further minimize your rolling resistance. Latex tubes are also less likely to suffer a pinch f–t because of their suppleness; they are less likely to get caught between the rim and the ground, which is what causes these “snake bites.” I also find them to be more comfortable. I like to use latex tubes on race day, and butyl for training. If you’ve never tried latex tubes, give ‘em a whirl. You just might love them.
Much more important the kind of tube you use is what you put in it, and by that, I mean air. When Mr. Dunlop invented the pneumatic, which is a fancy way of saying “air-filled,” tire back in 1887 for his sons tricycle, he changed the world. The pneumatic tire is probably the single most important invetion in the history of the bicycle.
When you look at track bikes, which do fine with no brakes, shifters, or much of anything else, you realize that the essence of the bicycle is really the two wheels. And it is the pneumatic tire that makes those two wheels so useful. Without tires, bicycles would be much less fast and comfortable. But, of course, the real question for us is not whether or not to use air, but how much air to use. Which brings us to commandments #4 and #5
Thou shalt not over inflatest thine tires.
Thou shalt inflatest thine tires regularly.
Commandment Four deals with the typical modern mentality of “if some is good, more is better.” This is not true. On most tires, this is why the manufacturer often writes “Max PSI” instead of “Recommended PSI.” They know that many of us will put in the max. So they just swap recommended with max, and suddenly people put in the right amount. Some manufacturers, for whatever reason, have taken advantage of this in an odd way and have started marketing the higher maximum inflation pressure of their tires.
I find this to be very odd, because it doesn’t really mean anything. But that is marketing for you. The standard rule of thumb is that for a rider of about 160lbs., which is guess is “average,” on 23mm tires, which are “standard,” the right pressure is about 115psi. If you weigh closer to 130 lbs., the you can go down 5psi. If you are closer to 200lbs., then up 5psi is a good idea.
If you are riding in the wet or really rough roads, down 5psi is a good idea. And if you are riding wider (25mm tires), then go down about 10psi. On narrower tires (20mm tires), go up 10psi. This are just some helpful baselines. But, unless you are getting on the velodrome, you don’t need to be maxing out that floor pump or wishing you had a pump that went to 250psi. Anywhere in that 110-120psi range is great for 23mm tires, 95-105 is great for 25mm, and 125-135 is great for 20mm tires.
The differences in PSI won’t make a huge difference to your racing. If you get outside that range on the highside, you risk tire blowoff, which can be a very exciting and also very hazardous experience. On the lowside, you are at great risk for a f–t. All tubes lose some pressure over time (with latex tubes losing most of their pressure overnight), so it is important to pump your tires regularly. I pump mine before every ride, which means basically every day. It is an easy habit to get into, and if you don’t ride daily, it is a necessary habit.
Anyway, I hope this provide some helpful tips. The differences between certain brands of tire can be striking, so if you are thinking about testing some new tires, take them out for a spin. Tires are one the cheapest ways to make a big difference in your speed.
Choosing the right tire and inflating it properly can make as much as a minute over an Olympic distance triathlon (25 miles), 2-3 minutes over a 70.3 race, and 5+ minutes over an Ironman. So if you head out on some new tires, and they feel faster, they very well might be.
Until next time, here’s hoping for constant tailwinds and clean roads…






